Skip to Content

Make Game Day Awesome with Milky Way Pie

Make Game Day Awesome with Milky Way Pie
Milky Way Ice Cream Pie Recipe #shop

Football + Milky Way Ice Cream Pie = WIN. Go team!

Sundays are designated “football days” in our house. I get a little bit excited to watch the Cowboys (and the Chargers), but to me it mostly means a day of decompressing in front of the television while the kids play on the floor and occasionally poke their heads up from their blocks or crayons to watch a few plays (as Jack gets older, he’s much more interested…and it’s lots of fun to watch him get excited when the Cowboys score!). We don’t get out to many games – our tailgating experiences are few and far between – but we often party like we’re tailgating – even if it’s just from our couch.

Today, I have a whole new level of deliciousness to share with you. The Milky Way Ice Cream Pie. This recipe is courtesy of my mother, who knows how to do dessert. 

The best part of this dessert is how amazing it tastes. But also great? There’s no baking involved, your kids can help make it, and it serves a lot of people (it’s pretty rich…which means a little slice will go a long way!).

Here’s what you’ll need:

  • 2 (7 oz.) packages of Milky Way Bites (or Snickers…the original recipe called for Snickers)
  • 1 prepared chocolate cookie pie crust (availabe in the baking section at your grocery store)
  • 1 pint ice cream (vanilla would be fine – I used Vanilla with Caramel and Fudge Swirl)
  • 1 cup caramel sauce
  • 1 small bag chocolate chips
Milky Way Bites #shop

Milky Way Bites are perfect for this recipe – they’re little and unwrapped, so you don’t have to waste any time unwrapping them all!

Here’s how to make Milky Way Ice Cream Pie:

Line the bottom of your pie crust with the Milky Way bites (this is a fun and kid-friendly activity your little helpers can easily do themselves). 

Milky Way Pie Recipe #shop

Kids will love lining the bottom of the pie crust with the little Milky Way bites!

Pour one cup of caramel over the top of the Milky Way bites. This is also a fun kid activity (while supervised) – my oldest loved pouring the caramel into all the nooks and crannies. I made sure the caramel sauce was room temperature so it was easy to pour. Once you’ve poured in the caramel, stick it in the freezer for a few hours.

Milky Way Pie Caramel #shop

Mmmmm. Caramel.

Once the caramel is frozen, take out your ice cream and let it soften for a bit. You want it to be spreadable, but not runny. Spread the ice cream over the frozen caramel (I didn’t use a whole pint…you’ll just need to use enough to make a nice layer). Put the pie back into the freezer…you want the ice cream to harden up again. I covered it with some foil first, because I don’t like the taste of ice cream that’s been exposed to the air in the freezer.

Milky Way Ice Cream #shop

Try not to eat all the ice cream. Or am I the only one who does that?

Once the ice cream has hardened, melt your chocolate chips in a double boiler or the microwave (if you’ve never melted chocolate chips before, it’s easy…I just dump them in a microwave-safe bowl, heat them for 45 seconds or so, stir, and then heat for another 30 seconds and stir again…that seems to do the trick).

Pour the melted chocolate over the ice cream, using a big spoon to flatten it out a bit. Then, take the remaining Milky Way bites and stick them around the edge of the pie in the chocolate.

Note: go easy on the chocolate. You’re going to need to cut through it – and eat it – and in this case, more isn’t always better (that tip is courtesy of The Girl Who Used Too Much Chocolate, aka ME).

Stick it right back into the freezer.

Milky Way Chocolate Pie #shop

Leave it in the freezer for several hours. When ready to serve, let it sit out for about five minutes before cutting. You’ll need a sharp knife to cut through (it’s pretty hard!). 

And then…eat it all while you’re rooting for your favorite team.

Even if you don’t love Football, game day is still a big WIN with a dessert like this. 

Do you have any special desserts you like to serve up on Game Day?


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

OMG this looks so yummy…I would so make this for my family but with my diet I don’t think I could pass it up.. I will totally save this until I can sneak a bite. ๐Ÿ™‚

There’s no such thing as too much chocolate. Try heating your knife blade before cutting, or running it under hot water. Works like a charm!

Such a great idea! I posted about the coupon, now I have a recipe! Thanks!!!

Yeah, I’m thinking there’s no such thing as too much chocolate, either. LOL! This looks to die for! And thanks a bunch for the coupon!

Umm can I stop drooling now? No? Okay fine. It’s worth it. This is amazing! I wish I could just eat my screen and taste. Okay that was weird. Sorry. I get weird when I see amazing food, haha.

That looks like a great way to use up some Halloween candy!

I’m so full right now that looking at this makes me sick but I’m not sure that i could pass it up! Chocolate…. ๐Ÿ˜‰

Okay, this looks AMAZING NEIGHBOR. Nudge me next time you make this!

This looks so rich and delicious! I have a thing for ice cream cake/pie… I might just attempt this – you made it look so easy!

I kinda love you right now. Milk Way is my favorite candy bar! I’m definitely going to try this recipe, it looks so good!

I am SO going to make this! I LOVE Caramel. Pinned for later, thanks!

This looks SO good. Too good really! Thanks for the coupon.

OMG Carrie that looks soooo good! I want it right now! LOL

One word. Yum. Like really, seriously, yum.

I LOVE Milky Way so I bet I’d love this pie! I like to chop up Milky Ways and put them in my brownies but never thought to add them to pies before! What a great idea ๐Ÿ™‚

Good golly but that looks amazing! I bet my kids would love it too.

I love how it’s so easy that kids can help make it!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x